This cupcake is a mish-mash of things I wanted to try.
First I saw rainbow cupcakes. I had several boxes of cake mix sitting around (they were on sale at the Teeter recently), so I figured I could use my gel icing colors to dye the cake batter and not fuss with also trying a made-from-scratch cake.
Second, I wanted to try a new frosting (plain buttercream is alright....). The author of this blog I think also feels "ehh" about buttercream (it's too, too sweet for me). And she swears this stuff is the bomb-shizzle. Originally I was going to make a chocolate frosting whenever I made the yellow cake (because nicole loves her some yellow cake + chocolate frosting) but figured the brown of the chocolate frosting might be a little...iffy...with the rainbow extravaganza. So I will just try the vanilla frosting.
Thirdly, I was using a butter (yellow) cake with a vanilla frosting, so I thought I could also throw in a little chocolate...in the form of making hi-hats. I decided only to do half with the hi-hats so I have a side-by-side comparison.
I guess you could call these "Rainbow Cupcakes with Vanilla Swiss Meringue Butter Cream...some with Formal Wear"
I didn't take any pictures of the colored cake batter. It was a bit time consuming (not hard, but it takes more effort than just plopping the cake batter into cupcake pans...you have to color several small batches of cake batter then plop it into said cupcake pans). Here is what I did with the colors:
- I used the wilton gel icing colors. If you want to make a rainbow of colors you could get away with just buying a red, yellow and blue (and make orange, green and purple). I happened to have green as well, so I used that instead of making it.
- I used a toothpick to dip into the gel colors and then swirled the toothpick into the portion of cake batter to distribute it. You can always add more color but you can't take away color, so it is best to start gradually
- I divided the batter (Betty Crocker Super Moist Butter Yellow cake mix--I didn't have any white cake mix, but this definitely needs to be done with "lighter" color batters) into pretty equal portions, but if you want more of one color, divide it however you like.
- red (wilton no taste red)
- equal-ish amounts of red + yellow (wilton lemon yellow)= orange
- yellow
- green (wilton leaf green), alternately, you could do blue + yellow
- blue (wilton royal blue)
- two parts red + one part blue = purple (I found that equalish amounts of blue and red gave a kinda greyish color.) This made it slightly less unappealing but we'll see what the color looks like baked up.
- I started with the purple and went backwards through the rainbow. I just plopped the batter into the cupcake liners and two mini-round pans (so I can have a mini-cake...yay!) at random. I didn't try to be pretty or fancy or what not.
I baked per the package directions. Although they baked a little too long and are a little extra golden (brown...) so the exterior colors look a little wonky (I blame my insatiable blog reader(s) because I started writing this blog as they were baking and didn't realize what time it was!). Also, my mini-round pans domed like no body's business. My cupcakes also domed (beautifully) but the mini-rounds are ridiculous.
I don't know why the cupcake picture isn't turned. It is turned in my photo editing software. I did the same thing to the minicake photo as the cupcakes but only one turned. I just dunno. Also, ignore my dirty stove. Anywho. So I snacked on one of the minicakes during the day. It was good. Cake mix...hard to screw it up.
On Sunday I made the frosting. I wasn't sure if it would turn out because some people say they have issues getting it to be thick enough to pipe onto cupcakes, so I only made a half batch (the full batch requires 4 egg whites and 2 sticks of butter plus some sugar). I followed the directions on the website and it turned out well. Once the sugar/egg white mixture was ready I just threw it into the stand mixer and let it go for about 7 minutes. The stuff kinda looks like marshmallow fluff. I added in the butter and kept mixing and eventually the frosting started making this definite "slapping" sound so I knew it was ready.
The texture of this frosting is just silky. It's amazing. I have two notes about this recipe. It did take about 30 minutes from start to finish (not counting the time to warm the butter to room temp) with having to heat the egg white/sugar mixture and all the beating, so this isn't going to be a 5 minute-wham-bam-thank-you-ma'am frosting. Also, I used a suspiciously old stick of butter...and I can taste it in the frosting. The vanilla flavoring almost covers it. But lesson learned: DO NOT USE OLD SKANKY BUTTER FOR THIS RECIPE!!!! This made me glad that I did not make the full batch, but I will definitely be making this frosting again--and trying some flavored versions (like making strawberry SMBC but using my homemade strawberry jam instead of store bought stuff!)
This is a cross section of a frosted cupcake (I frosted a few for taste purposes--I mean...the cake might have also canceled out the wonky butter flavor--and to make the hi-hats since the chocolate might also help cancel out the wonky butter flavor). See the rainbow? FUN! It's hard to see the orange vs red in the photo..but they are both there. Now I don't know if I can handle having an un-dyed cake after this. It needs to be a color, if not multiple colors. I mean...look at it! It's just a box mix...but throw a little color in...and yipee!!!! Plus...I also have enough of the gel coloring to last me about 10 lifetimes.
The hi-hats were essentially chocolate mixed with a little oil. You dip the frosting of the cupcake in (or if you are insane the entire (unwrapped) cupcake) and wait until the chocolate set. The blog I got it off of said hers set in about 15 minutes. After 2 hours mine were firmer but still a bit soft. I don't know if it was a bit too warm or humid in my apartment, but I'm sure a quick trip into the fridge/freezer would solve that.
I thought the chocolate with the vanilla was lovely. Minus the wanky butter taste. The chocolate still couldn't cover that. But had this process been skunky-butter free these would have been totally delightful. Unfortunately the rest were thrown away. Next time...next time...
In summary:
- rainbow cupcakes: a little extra work (and mess to clean up) but fun
- swiss meringue butter cream frosting: fantastic--as long as you don't use wonky butter
- hi-hats: great for a taste of chocolate